A recent incident involving budget airline Ryanair has reignited discussions about the strict enforcement of baggage policies and additional charges for passengers. On February 4, 2025, a Ryanair passenger, Ruby Flanagan, was charged €60 (£50) for carrying a 750ml water bottle separately from her designated carry-on baggage while boarding a flight from Dublin to London Stansted. The enforcement of this fee has sparked backlash among passengers and travel experts alike, raising concerns about transparency and fairness in airline policies.
Ryanair’s Baggage Policy and the Water Bottle Incident
Ryanair’s baggage policy states that passengers with a Basic Fare ticket are permitted to carry one small personal bag measuring up to 40 x 20 x 25 cm. Any additional items, including jackets, duty-free shopping, or, in this case, a water bottle, must fit within this allocated bag. If a passenger fails to comply with these rules, they may be required to pay an extra fee at the boarding gate.
Flanagan’s experience highlights how strictly Ryanair enforces this policy. The airline charged her a fee because she was carrying her water bottle outside of her bag, making it an additional item. Despite her protests, she was required to pay the fee before being allowed to board her flight. The incident quickly went viral, drawing criticism from many who believe the fee was excessive and unfair.
Public Reaction and Expert Opinions
The reaction to this event has been mixed. Many travelers expressed frustration, stating that a water bottle should not be considered an extra piece of luggage. Social media users called the charge “ridiculous” and accused Ryanair of exploiting passengers for minor infractions.
However, travel expert Simon Calder weighed in on the debate, noting that while the charge may seem harsh, it is within Ryanair’s official guidelines. He emphasized that budget airlines operate with strict baggage policies to keep fares low, and passengers must be aware of and adhere to these regulations to avoid unexpected costs.
Budget Airlines and Hidden Fees
This incident sheds light on a broader issue regarding budget airlines and their fee structures. Ryanair, like many low-cost carriers, offers cheap base fares but makes up for lost revenue by charging for additional services such as baggage, seat selection, and even minor infractions like carrying an extra item. These fees are a major source of income for the airline, but they often catch passengers off guard.
Frequent travelers have learned to navigate these policies carefully, ensuring that they consolidate all their belongings into their designated personal item. Still, new or occasional travelers may find themselves surprised by stringent enforcement and unexpected costs.
How to Avoid Extra Fees on Budget Airlines
To avoid facing similar charges when flying with Ryanair or other budget airlines, passengers should take the following precautions:
-
Pack strategically: Ensure all personal items, including water bottles, are placed inside your allowed carry-on bag before reaching the boarding gate.
-
Check baggage policies before travel: Each airline has different rules regarding baggage and additional charges, so reviewing policies in advance can help prevent surprises.
-
Consider priority boarding or additional baggage options: If you anticipate needing more space, purchasing a priority boarding ticket or checked baggage in advance can be a cost-effective way to avoid high fees at the gate.
-
Stay informed on airline practices: Understanding how budget airlines operate can help passengers make informed decisions about their travel expenses.
Conclusion
While Ryanair’s enforcement of baggage policies is within its rights, the water bottle incident has sparked debate about the fairness of such strict rules. As budget airlines continue to rely on additional fees as a key part of their business model, passengers must stay vigilant and informed to avoid unexpected costs. Whether this incident will lead to policy changes remains to be seen, but it serves as a reminder for travelers to always double-check their airline’s regulations before heading to the airport.